A member’s card gets declined on the day their loan payment is due.
They call in, a little flustered, and halfway through the conversation they decide they’d rather pay next week and also ask about a hardship option. The script never planned for any of this. Whether your AI handles that call well is the real test, and it’s the one more institutions will start giving in 2027.
The expensive part of a payment isn’t the payment
PayNearMe’s Payment Experience Gap Report puts numbers on it. For every $1.20 a business spends to process a payment, another $6.02 goes to the operations, support and customer experience work needed to complete it. Most of that spend comes from payments that don’t go as planned.
Those are also the moments when members want a human nearby. PwC found that 61% of borrowers want a person involved when problems come up.
The prediction: exceptions become the exam
PayNearMe expects banks and credit unions to stop pilot-testing AI on routine requests and start judging it on the hard stuff. Think of these three:
- The declined payment
- The missed due date
- The member who changes direction mid-call
The AI that lowers the true cost per payment will resolve these moments within policy. When it can’t, it will hand off to a person who already has the full context, so the member never has to start over. That requires AI that is flexible enough to follow the member and controlled enough to stay compliant.
Flexibility and control, at the same time
Han Shu of PayNearMe describes the challenge this way: “Building AI for regulated industries means delivering three things at once: compliance, performance and a natural user experience. A rigid interaction can make compliance easier, but that’s not how people communicate. The technical challenge is giving customers the flexibility to interact naturally while maintaining the controls needed to operate safely.”
In other words, a locked-down script is easy to audit and miserable to talk to. People wander, interrupt and change their minds. The AI has to wander with them without leaving the guardrails.
What this means for you
If you’re evaluating AI for member payments, don’t let a demo of the easy calls win you over. Ask to see the declined card, the late payment and the mid-call U-turn. Then ask what happens when the AI hits its limit, and whether the person who picks up knows everything that was already said. That’s where your costs, and your members’ patience, are really decided.